Thursday, November 5, 2015

The Advocate's People of the Year: The Supreme Court of the United States

On June 26, 2015, the lives of gay Americans were forever changed when the Supreme Court handed down its decision on Obergefell v. Hodges – declaring marriage to be a constitutionally protected right for same-sex couples.  The monumental and life-changing decision by the Supreme Court has changed America’s landscape for LGBT citizens and has earned all 9 Justices the title of The Advocate’s 2015 “People of the Year” – with a special nod to Justice Anthony Kennedy, the author of the beautifully written majority opinion.
 
The Supreme Court’s historic ruling on marriage equality has turned the tide for so many LGBT citizens that had been relegated to second class citizenship. The Court’s decision was an enormous step forward for gay and lesbian Americans toward becoming equal citizens under the law. As a result of the decision, the United States’s role as a world influencer has also inspired advocates across the globe to continue their fight for a brighter and more equal future for LGBT individuals worldwide. 
 
While The Advocate’s “People of the Year” designation recognizes all nine Justices in the 5-4 decision that decreed marriage equality the law of the land, special recognition goes to Justice Anthony Kennedy, who captured the majority’s opinion in an almost poetic decision. Kennedy captured the 5-4 majority decision in writing that gay and lesbian Americans deserve “equal dignity in the eyes of the law” and that the government must recognize gay people’s inherent dignity, not bestow it.  The dissenting Justices – all four of whom penned a dissent – deserve recognition as well for their role in propelling equality. Their dissenting opinions offered up an array of conflicting arguments, which had the effect of invalidating each other, unintentionally boosting the impact of the majority opinion.
 
The Supreme Court’s ruling on Obergefell v. Hodes declaring marriage to be a constitutionally protected right for same-sex couples has ushered in a new age for LGBT Americans; absolutely pivotal toward LGBT citizens becoming completely equal under the law.  Without the Supreme Court’s independence and position as the ultimate arbiter of the law, gays and lesbians in America would still be denied access to the fundamental institution of marriage.